Google Confirms AI Mode Queries Monetize Below Standard Search Ads

Google says AI Mode queries monetize below standard search ads, slowing search revenue growth to 12%. Reddit's Reviews now covers 10,000 products with no paid placement for brands.
By Tom Whitfield
3 min readAt a glance
- Google search ad revenue grew 12% in the quarter, down from 15% a year earlier, per the Oct. 28 earnings call.
- Google CBO Philipp Schindler said AI Mode queries monetize at a lower rate than standard search.
- Reddit Reviews launched Nov. 10 as a gradual U.S. rollout covering roughly 10,000 products, with no paid product placement.
- New AI ad formats launched within two weeks across ChatGPT, Bing, Yahoo Scout and Google's multiturn ads.
- AdExchanger reported some advertisers moved budget from Google to Meta, though not a proven market-wide shift.
Google's chief business officer Philipp Schindler confirmed on the company's Oct. 28 earnings call that strong growth in AI Mode queries had reduced search revenue growth, because those queries monetize at a lower rate than standard search ads. Search ad revenue grew 12 percent in the quarter, down from 15 percent a year earlier, even as query growth reached its fastest pace in five years.
The admission gives advertisers a rare official number for a question they ask at every platform launch: what does a new product take from the format they already pay for? AdExchanger's summary of reporting by The Information adds that some advertisers have moved budget to Meta after concluding their Google spend was not delivering results. Those account-level cases show real frustration, but they do not prove a market-wide shift from Google to Meta. The same reporting notes that Meta's newer AI products, including its Muse agent, do not compete with its core ads business.
What changes for advertisers right now?
The practical warning sign is delivery, not cost. Cost per result is the number most teams watch, but a format that cannot spend its budget is the earlier warning. When a brand cannot get its ads in front of enough people, that is a delivery problem before it is a cost problem.
The number of places to buy has multiplied in two weeks:
- ChatGPT's visual ads have started appearing.
- Bing has shown ads atop responses in AI Mode and AI Overviews.
- Yahoo's Scout chatbot has left beta.
- Google announced a multiturn ad format for the U.S. and wider AI Mode ads abroad.
Available inventory in AI search remains limited. The author, Temilola Agbede, writing for Inc.com, advises testing fewer formats with enough money behind each: a budget spread across five new formats leaves too little in any one to produce anything tangible.
Why is Reddit's move different?
Reddit announced Reddit Reviews on Nov. 10, a gradual U.S. rollout of AI-organized summaries of what Redditors say about roughly 10,000 products. In Reddit's own words, "Businesses can't pay to have products featured." A Reddit spokesperson said the platform takes no cut of purchases made through the buy button. Brands and retailers can still supply catalog details such as prices, images and purchase links.
That removes the paid lever entirely. Shoppers are skeptical of content a brand has influenced, which is why a summary the brand cannot buy into persuades more. It also shifts the burden: there is no paid way to scrub a bad thread, so what remains is how quickly and publicly a brand responds in the channels it controls.
Speed is the issue. Conversation about a brand moves faster when it turns negative. Anyone can leave a review on a Google listing without confirming a purchase, and holiday shoppers are starting their search on AI platforms that draw on reviews and forum threads. A thread can shape a purchase before a brand knows the conversation exists. Tracking mentions, to catch positive momentum and growing negative sentiment early, is now table stakes.
What stays in a brand's control?
When a platform changes what it sells, a brand controls two things: where it places test dollars, and how fast it answers. The column poses three questions for the week ahead. Would you notice a channel change first in cost per result or in whether the budget still spends? Which one or two new AI formats would you fund well enough to learn something? And if a negative thread about your best seller started this afternoon, who would see it first, and where would you answer?
Every platform will keep launching products that serve its own assortment. A brand can treat every launch like one of its own and ask what the new product takes from the old one before the budget moves.
Source: inc.com
Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.