MoJ inquiry weighs whether Brand's YouTube statement breached prison rules

The Ministry of Justice is examining whether Russell Brand's innocence statement, read on YouTube by his wife, broke rules preventing serious distress to victims. Google says its teams are investigating.
By Tom Whitfield
3 min readAt a glance
- Russell Brand is serving a 10-and-a-half-year sentence after conviction on 5 November at Southwark crown court for rape and three sexual assaults.
- Google suspended Brand's channel from the YouTube partner programme in September 2023; it has not monetised since.
- The MoJ inquiry tests rules against 'serious distress' to victims, plus the crimes' notoriety and time since verdict.
- The government has no legal power to compel Google to remove the video.
- Brand is expected to remain at category C HMP Littlehey despite reports of a move.
A Ministry of Justice inquiry is examining whether Russell Brand broke prisoner media rules by issuing a YouTube statement protesting his innocence, days after ministers asked for the video's removal. The video, in which Brand's wife Laura Gallacher read a message from the jailed sex offender insisting he was not guilty of rape and sexual assault, has remained on the platform.
Brand is serving a 10-and-a-half-year sentence after Southwark crown court convicted him on 5 November of one count of rape and three sexual assaults. He is held at HMP Littlehey, a category C specialist prison for sex offenders in Cambridgeshire.
The inquiry's focus is whether the statement breached rules designed to prevent "serious distress" to victims of crime, according to the source. Other deciding factors include the "notoriety" of the crimes and the length of time between the verdict and the statement.
Greater Manchester mayor Andy Burnham has called on Google, YouTube's owner, to take the statement down.
What do the prison media rules say?
Official guidance states a prison governor must decide whether to permit a prisoner's media access. The governor must consider that "serious distress to victims of the prisoner and/or outrage to public sensibilities is not likely to result from the broadcast". The guidance adds this is likely if "the prisoner's crimes or conduct are recent, notorious or horrific".
The rules also state that correspondence likely to be published or broadcast "must not contain material about the prisoner's own crime or past offences or those of others, except where it consists of serious representations about conviction or sentence".
The inquiry is understood to be weighing Brand's right to protest his innocence. A strict protocol governs how such statements are issued and whether permission was sought beforehand.
Recent reports claimed Brand is likely to be moved to a category A or B prison after protesting his innocence. It is understood no such proposal exists, and he is likely to remain at Littlehey.
What power does the government have over YouTube?
The UK prime minister said on Thursday night he "wouldn't leap" to changing the law to force social media companies to remove such content. He added: "I would call on those social media companies to take these interviews down. You know, why are we having to hear from him? We shouldn't be, and certainly [the victims] shouldn't be hearing from him."
The government has no power to compel Google to remove the video but has been in "dialogue" with the firm. A Downing Street spokesperson said: "The prime minister's position on this is that Russell Brand's victims deserve peace, and we've heard enough from him."
The spokesperson noted YouTube "acted before when they suspended Brand's account from making money" and said: "Given he has been convicted of rape by a jury of his peers, we trust that they will act again."
A Google spokesperson said: "We're aware of the new content and our teams are investigating. We suspended Russell Brand's channel from the YouTube partner programme in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then."
No 10, asked repeatedly whether Burnham would welcome the video's removal and the channel's disabling, told reporters: "Removal ultimately depends on YouTube and the platform's terms and conditions."
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch told BBC Radio 4's Today programme she would not immediately demand removal if in power. "My personal opinion is that Russell Brand has been convicted. He is guilty under the law. His wife is a separate person. She can make the protestations that she likes," she said. She added that "immediately demanding the private platforms take things down without looking at exactly whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from".
The MoJ inquiry's finding will determine whether the statement triggers disciplinary consequences inside prison, while any takedown now rests solely with Google's own investigation.
Source: theguardian.com
Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.
Related articles
UK government asks YouTube to deactivate Russell Brand’s account
Google refuses UK request to remove Russell Brand prison video
UK lawmakers call for criminal liability for camming platforms
UK bans specific porn categories with up to five-year prison terms
Moderation Gap: How 'Harmless' Images Become Deadly for Pakistani Women