Creator Economy

No Shared Creator Taxonomy, No Standard Pricing: Why Marketers Can't Agree

What exactly counts as a creator? The industry still can’t agree
What exactly counts as a creator? The industry still can’t agreeAI-generated

23% of marketers want a unified creator taxonomy, per IAB. But General Mills, Shutterfly and Rothy's each define creators differently, leaving pricing and measurement unstandardized.

By Grace Kim

3 min read

At a glance

  • At least 23% of marketers say the industry would benefit from a unified creator taxonomy, per the IAB's latest creator economy report.
  • General Mills tiers creators into five groups, with mid creators defined as 500,000 to 1.5 million followers.
  • Shutterfly uses three tiers: tastemakers at 1 million-plus followers, content creators from a couple hundred to 2,000-plus, and influencers in between.
  • Rothy's defines tastemakers by cultural relevance rather than follower count, spanning TikTok stars to Substack writers.
  • VML organizes creators by campaign role — salespeople, brand ambassadors, product collaborators — rather than follower tiers.

At least 23% of marketers say the industry needs a unified creator taxonomy, according to the IAB's latest creator economy report — and that number may undersell the problem. Every major brand Digiday spoke with defines "creator" differently, which means measurement, contracts and fee structures still can't be standardized across the industry.

The definitional chaos starts at the top of the funnel. "That's the blurry line. Who's a mega influencer and who's a celebrity? I don't know anymore," said Mindy Murray, director of influencer and content at General Mills.

How do brands actually tier creators?

General Mills runs a five-tier system. Celebrity sits at the top, where partnerships often extend beyond social into product design and formula work. Mega creators sit just below celebrity partnerships. Mid creators range from 500,000 to 1.5 million social followers. Then come super fans or brand advocates — dedicated creators posting consistently on the brand's behalf. Finally, there's friends and family: General Mills' organic influencer group, who also act as brand advocates.

Shutterfly takes a different route with three tiers. Tastemakers are social media stars with one million or more followers, handpicked for major campaigns. Content creators sit at the other end, with anywhere from a couple hundred to more than 2,000 followers. Influencers fall somewhere in between, Callie Worthington, vp of brand marketing and creative at Shutterfly, told Digiday.

Notably, Shutterfly doesn't tie an internal pay scale to that codification. It does expect bigger creators — tastemakers and influencers — to command bigger budgets.

Rothy's uses "tastemaker" too, but the shoe brand defines its classifications less by follower count and more by cultural relevance, said Anna Doré, vp of brand and communications at Rothy's. A tastemaker could be a TikTok star or a Substack writer. Rothy's calls its affiliate creators "the lower funnel crater and conversion types," Doré said.

What does the disagreement change for practitioners?

Agencies don't follow the same guidelines either. VML organizes creators by their role in a campaign — salespeople, brand ambassadors, product collaborators and so on. The taxonomy isn't strict, said Noah Eisemann, global executive director of creator and influencer at VML.

"Every influencer is a creator, but not every creator is an influencer," Eisemann said.

The creator economy has expanded well beyond product-selling. Creators have been hired as actors in Super Bowl spots. They've been brought on as product collaborators. Some now operate as creative agencies, helping brands ideate and execute campaigns. Kim Kardashian is as much a content creator as she is an influencer, depending on what the brand asks of her, Eisemann added.

His proposed fix is functional rather than categorical. "The more useful standard may be a shared way of defining the role a creator is playing in a particular strategy — because that's ultimately what should determine how we value the partnership and what success looks like," Eisemann said.

Why the taxonomy gap matters for budgets

A brand's tiering setup directly influences how creators are evaluated, how their impact is measured and how they're deployed in campaigns. When those assumptions differ across partners, money gets misallocated.

"When expectations, budgets, and measurement rely on different assumptions, effective work can be undervalued, and investment becomes harder to justify or sustain," said Stefani Stamatiou, CEO of Americas at HYDP creator marketing agency.

Across the industry, no conventional naming system exists — Digiday notes even its own staffers couldn't agree on what separates a creator from an influencer. And as more money pours into the creator economy, marketers are increasingly demanding measurement tied to business outcomes, not vanity metrics.

That pressure may force the standardization the IAB report hints at. "Greater clarity around inputs and expected outcomes would make it easier to set goals, allocate budgets, and define the role creators play within the broader advertising landscape," Stamatiou said.

Whether brands adopt a shared taxonomy or settle on role-based definitions, expect the measurement debate to intensify as creator budgets grow.

Original: iab.com

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.

More from Grace Kim →

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »