Skims' $148 Advent Calendar Backlash: Data Suggests It Was No Stunt

Skims offered refunds or store credit after its $148 advent calendar flopped, but data shows negative posts outnumbering positive ones eight to one in early November.
By Tom Whitfield
3 min readAt a glance
- Negative posts about Skims' $148 advent calendar beat positive ones eight to one between Nov. 2 and Nov. 11, per Starlight Analytics.
- Negativity rose from 13% of Skims mentions on Nov. 6 to 76% on Nov. 11.
- Skims offered every calendar buyer a full refund or $148 store credit; refunds require returning the box.
- Nearly 60% of shoppers overspend a gift card balance by an average of $73, per Blackhawk Network 2026 research.
- Skims raised $225 million last year at a $5 billion valuation.
Skims' $148 12-day advent calendar drew eight negative social posts for every positive one between November 2 and November 11, according to tracking by consumer insights firm Starlight Analytics. The company has offered every buyer a full refund or store credit of equal value, but marketers remain split on whether the damage is containable.
The backlash started with unboxing videos. "We might be on track for the worst advent calendar I've ever opened," content creator Kayla Ryan said in a TikTok video this week. "I could get these at Dollar Tree," she added, pulling three unpacked hair ties from the day three slot.
The box contained keychains, bobby pins, scrunchies and hair ties. It held none of the bodysuits or loungewear that built Kim Kardashian's brand. Videos like Ryan's flooded social platforms for days before Skims responded.
A spokesperson told other outlets the company "personally contacted every customer who purchased the calendar and offered them a choice of a full refund or a SKIMS credit to put towards other products." Skims did not respond to multiple requests for comment from Fortune.
What does the refund offer change for buyers?
The catch sits in the terms. Cash refunds require customers to return the calendar, while those choosing store credit keep it. That detail fueled speculation the flop was deliberate rage-bait.
"Skims knew what they were doing with that advent calendar. I'd bet money it was intentional," Jessica Tillery, senior vice president of brand communications at Allison Worldwide, wrote on LinkedIn. "Every dollar spent over that $148 credit is new revenue for them. Every person who comes back to shop with that credit is a repeat purchaser."
The spending behavior Tillery describes is real. Nearly 60% of shoppers say they exceed a gift card's balance when redeeming it, spending $73 more on average, according to Blackhawk Network's 2026 research. A 2025 study by Northwestern Kellogg lecturer Ata Jami found shoppers treat refunded money more freely than regular cash, because it does not sting the same way.
Why researchers reject the stunt theory
Marketers and consumer researchers who spoke with Fortune largely disagree with the rage-bait reading. Starlight's data shows negativity intensifying as chatter declined: negative posts made up 13% of Skims mentions on November 6 and 76% on November 11, based on a partial day of data.
"I don't buy the stunt theory," Chris Ribeiro, founder of Starlight Analytics and a marketing professor at Rutgers Business School, told Fortune. "Any time you alienate your core customer and make them feel stupid, that's bad marketing in my opinion." He added that "this store credit is the customer's own $148, following a poor experience."
Nataly Kelly, chief marketing officer at Zappi, traced the failure upstream. "No brand wakes up hoping its holiday launch gets called overpriced junk," she said. "This is a product that never got checked against what shoppers think $148 should buy."
Zappi's research shows only one in 10 consumers sticks solely to name brands, meaning loyalty cannot rescue a weak product. "A logo can't carry a box of hair ties anymore," Kelly said.
The longer-term cost
Ben Metcalfe, founder of BlackFire Marketing, called store credit "smarter than just a refund" because it draws shoppers back. Roughly 43% of Americans hold unused gift cards, vouchers or store credit, averaging $244 unspent, per a 2024 Bankrate survey.
Metcalfe expects Skims to absorb the cost of one calendar. The larger risk is memory. "Negative attention can boost awareness, but awareness isn't loyalty," he said. "Brands can survive a single viral mistake, but they struggle when their customers start to see a pattern."
For a company that raised $225 million last year at a $5 billion valuation, the steepest price of the calendar may be measured in shopper trust rather than refunds.
Source: fortune.com
Tom Whitfield
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.