TikTok Beats Instagram on Engagement at Equal Reach, Report Finds
TikTok and Instagram brand posts reach the same ~78,000 people, but TikTok averages 3.9% engagement by views vs Instagram's 2.6%, per Dash Social's 2026 benchmark.
By Marcus Bennett
4 min readAt a glance
- TikTok averaged 3.9% engagement by views vs Instagram's 2.6% at equal reach of ~78,000 per post
- Study analyzed 1,343 TikTok and 3,313 Instagram brand accounts from Jan. 1 to June 30, 2026
- TikTok brand accounts grew followers 3.4% a month vs 0.6% on Instagram
- Reels led all formats on shares at 711 per post; carousels led views at 156,000 per post
- Media and entertainment brands hit 6.0% TikTok engagement, publishing 21 times a week
Brand posts on TikTok and Instagram reach roughly the same audience — about 78,000 people on average — yet TikTok converts that reach into half again as much engagement, averaging 3.9% by views against Instagram's 2.6%. That's the headline finding of Dash Social's "Issue 2 2026 Social Media Benchmark Report," which analyzed 1,343 TikTok accounts and 3,313 Instagram accounts belonging to global companies between Jan. 1 and June 30, 2026.
The benchmarks cover organic, boosted and promoted content, exclude paid ads, and apply to handles with at least 1,000 followers. The sample includes both Dash Social customers and non-customers, though some metrics — reach per post among them — draw on customer data only. Keep that caveat in mind before you reweight your content calendar.
What does the report change for format decisions?
TikTok videos averaged 149,800 views per post, 19% more than the 126,000 averaged by Instagram Reels. Instagram averaged 135,600 views per post across all formats. Carousels led every TikTok and Instagram format on raw reach, at 156,000 views per post — a useful signal if you've been treating them as an afterthought.
Sharing tells a different story. Reels averaged 711 shares per post, the highest of any format studied, ahead of Instagram images at 557, carousels at 456 and TikTok posts at 237. Reels also topped Instagram's internal format table on engagement rate by views at 2.9%, with images at 2.5% and carousels at 2.3%.
Audience growth skews hard toward TikTok
Brand accounts on TikTok grew followers 3.4% a month on average. Instagram managed 0.6%, with engagement by followers averaging just 0.4%. Posting volume was nearly identical: eight TikTok posts and nine Instagram posts per week on average.
Account size cut in opposite directions on the two platforms. On TikTok, engagement climbed with scale:
- Brands above 230,000 followers: 4.7% engagement rate by views
- 40,000–230,000 followers: 3.5%
- Under 40,000 followers: 3.2%
The largest TikTok brands posted 13 times a week and averaged 286,900 views and 530 shares per post. Smaller accounts grew fastest, adding followers at 5.4% a month against 1.8% for the biggest.
Instagram reversed the pattern. Accounts under 190,000 followers averaged 2.9% engagement by views, beating both the 190,000-to-1.1-million tier (2.4%) and accounts above 1.1 million (2.5%). Large Instagram brands posted 17 times a week and averaged 383,500 views per post.
Media brands dominate the industry breakdown
Across the report's 10 industries, media and entertainment brands posted most and performed strongest. On TikTok they published 21 times a week, averaging a 6.0% engagement rate by views and 974 shares per post. On Instagram they averaged 32 posts a week, 469,300 views per post and 2,700 shares per post.
The outliers are worth a second look. Luxury brands posted least on TikTok — three times a week — yet drew the highest views per post of any industry at 381,300. CPG brands grew TikTok followers fastest at 8.9% a month. Health and wellness trailed, averaging 59,100 views and a 2.5% engagement rate on TikTok.
How the other platforms compare
One methodological flag: Dash Social calculates engagement rate differently on each platform, so the cross-network numbers don't compare directly. With that in mind, the wider benchmarks run as follows:
- LinkedIn: 3 posts a week, 10.4% engagement rate (clicks, reactions, comments and reposts divided by impressions)
- X: 54 posts a week, 6.1% engagement rate, but follower growth of just 0.2% a month
- Facebook: 30 posts a week, 16,800 accounts reached and 0.8% engagement per post
- Pinterest: 26 posts a week, 1,700 impressions and 41 Pin clicks per post
- YouTube: 238,800 views per video, with viewers watching 85.5% of each video on average
For practitioners, the practical takeaway is that equal reach doesn't mean equal return: TikTok's engagement premium and its near-six-fold follower-growth edge suggest where incremental organic effort currently pays out. The next benchmark issue will show whether Instagram's format-level strengths — Reels shares in particular — can close that gap.
Source: netinfluencer.com
Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering money, funding and market shifts around Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.
Related articles
Metricool Pits Instagram Against TikTok for 2026 Planners
Instagram Leads 2026 Engagement Benchmarks at 4.2%, LinkedIn Close Behind
Education Sector's 2026 Social Benchmarks Set the Bar: Instagram Leads at 4.2%
TikTok Pays Under $1 Per 1,000 Views in 2026: What Actually Moves Reach
Brands Post 4% Sales Content or Less — and the Data Says That's Right