UBS Warns AI Agents Are Breaking the Internet's Human Eyeball Bet

UBS says AI agents are breaking the internet's human-eyeball model, and BofA rates 29% of Bending Spoons' 2027 revenue at high risk — but no cancellation data has shown up yet.
By Nathan Brooks
4 min readAt a glance
- BofA rates ~29% of Bending Spoons' projected 2027 revenue as high risk from AI agents, including AOL at $778.8 million.
- UBS's Hoffmann-Burchardi: "We believe the speed of AI disruption is still underappreciated by the markets."
- Meta's Muse agent app passed an estimated 10 million U.S. downloads in its first 40 days, per Sensor Tower.
- Experts estimate 10% to 40% of subscribers may not use the products they pay for.
- Bending Spoons reports third-quarter results Nov. 20; BofA rates it Underperform with a $38 price objective.
BofA Global Research rates about 29% of Bending Spoons' projected 2027 revenue as high risk from AI agents, in a Nov. 16 report that lands alongside a blunt UBS warning: "We believe the speed of AI disruption is still underappreciated by the markets."
The two notes, published the same day, attack the same assumption from different angles. Since the web's start, every checkout button and dashboard assumed a person sat behind the screen. AI agents that shop, compare and click on a user's behalf break that bargain.
What does 'B2A' mean for ad buyers?
Ulrike Hoffmann-Burchardi, chief investment officer for the Americas at UBS Wealth Management, put it plainly in a note and podcast released Monday: "Since its inception, the internet has been built for human eyeballs." Her shorthand for the shift: "We are moving from B2C (business to agent)."
Her example sounds mundane. A shopper tells an agent to find waterproof trail-running shoes under $150 that arrive by Thursday. The agent checks inventory, compares specs and buys. "AI agents do not have emotions," she said. "They don't care about a clever Super Bowl spot or a brightly colored retargeting banner."
The practical implication for marketers: SEO alone stops working. Brands that want agents to find them need machine-readable product data and real-time inventory feeds. Enterprise software takes the same hit — if one AI-augmented employee works at the speed of five to 10 people, companies stop buying seats, and agents talking straight to databases make dashboards obsolete.
The consumer side is already moving. Meta's Muse agent app passed an estimated 10 million U.S. downloads in its first 40 days, per Sensor Tower estimates reported in October, and personal-agent app Instinct said 40% of users had connected credit cards by week three, according to UBS.
How much of Bending Spoons' revenue is exposed?
BofA's analysts, Omar Dessouky and Ethan Liu, built their report around one line: "Inconvenience is the main moat against AI." Bending Spoons, the Milan-based buyer of more than 50 businesses including AOL, Vimeo, Eventbrite, Evernote and WeTransfer, profits from subscribers who never cancel because cancelling is a chore. An agent does chores.
The high-risk bucket breaks down by asset:
- AOL — $778.8 million in BofA's 2027 estimate; AI can compare its bundled security add-ons and replace its tech-help subscriptions
- Eventbrite — $403.1 million
- Evernote — $125.5 million, where "AI assistants become a new 'second brain'"
- WeTransfer sits at medium risk; Vimeo at low, since big video libraries are hard to move
BofA hasn't rated the remaining 53%. The analysts note experts estimated "10% to 40% of payers may not use the products they pay for."
Has any of this actually happened yet?
Not on the evidence, and both sides concede it. "We closely monitor our businesses' KPIs and haven't seen any signs that AI agents are driving cancellations or switching to alternative products," a Bending Spoons spokesperson told Fortune.
The BofA analysts largely agree, writing they "have yet to track data to test our hypotheses" and have seen nothing at large scale. The savings from cancelling AOL, WeTransfer, Evernote, Eventbrite or Vimeo run about $228 to $728 a year — "equivalent to a weekly cup of coffee." Their preliminary conclusion: "the value gained from switching to cheaper or better solutions rarely exceeds the cost of staying put." They see third-quarter organic growth risks "skewed mildly to the upside."
BofA rates the stock Underperform, with a $38 price objective against a $41.08 share price, mostly on valuation and deal returns. The company carried net debt of 205% of equity at the end of 2025, by BofA's count, and recently bought Airtable for $1.285 billion and Miro for $1.355 billion.
What's the precedent for inertia profits?
Economists have measured this moat before. In a 2006 study of 7,752 health-club members, Stefano DellaVigna and Ulrike Malmendier found people on monthly contracts paid more than $17 per expected visit when a 10-visit pass cost $10 a visit, and 2.31 months passed on average between a member's last workout and cancellation.
Regulators keep poking at it too. The Eighth Circuit vacated the FTC's "click-to-cancel" rule on procedural grounds in 2025; the agency reopened the rulemaking in March, per law firm Jones Day.
UBS closed its argument with a 2000 Fortune piece that asked "How Much Are Your Eyeballs Worth?" — Lycos was valued at $244 a pair back then. The next visitor may not have eyeballs at all. Bending Spoons reports third-quarter results Nov. 20, the first real-world test of whether its customers are still staying put.
Source: fortune.com
Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.
Related articles
AI agents don't care about your brand — and 47% of execs know it
AI Agents Could Steer Up to $385 Billion of US E-Commerce by 2030
Google Stock Fell 10% on AI Search Ads Slowdown While Meta Gains
Billion Dollar Boy Bets $100M-Plus on B2B Creator Marketing
Cloudflare Says AI Bots Scrape Thousands of Pages Per Reader Sent