Organic Strategy

Behind-the-Scenes Videos Outperform the Ads They Defend

Meet the marketers fighting AI suspicion—using advertising’s new secret weapon
Meet the marketers fighting AI suspicion—using advertising’s new secret weaponmerlinlightpainting / pixabay

Apple's BTS claymation video hit 197M views versus 32M for the ad itself. Brands now treat proof of human craft as core campaign strategy amid AI backlash.

By Grace Kim

4 min read

At a glance

  • Apple's BTS video for 'The Mighty Mac mini' earned 197M Instagram views vs 32M YouTube views for the spot itself.
  • Levi's 'Let's Get Fuzzy' stop-motion ad took 2,000 hours, with four hours of work per second of animation.
  • Prada's BTS video reached 2.8M views and 2,300+ comments thanking the brand for avoiding AI.
  • Dior denied AI use in its holiday film, attributing anomalies to 'automated interpolation'; LVMH did not respond to comment requests.
  • Apple's 'A Critter Carol' became its most-viewed holiday film ever with 141M social views.

Apple's behind-the-scenes claymation video pulled 197 million views on Instagram — roughly six times the 32 million the actual "The Mighty Mac mini" spot earned on YouTube. It's now the most-watched post ever on Apple's secondary account, @helloapple, and one of the brand's biggest social posts of all time. That gap is pushing behind-the-scenes footage from an industry afterthought to a core campaign asset.

The shift has a blunt trigger: audiences now assume anything animated might be AI. Levi's global CMO Kenny Mitchell says the behind-the-scenes film for the brand's stop-motion holiday ad "Let's Get Fuzzy" — which took 2,000 hours to make — was "central" to the strategy. When the campaign first posted on TikTok, one comment read "AI slop." The reply underneath: "No, this is stop motion."

"You almost want to make sure that you can show some of the verification and receipts for the hard work, effort, and craft that you're putting in," Mitchell says. Levi's production partner Blinkink spent four hours on every second of animation in the spot.

What does this change for marketers?

Proof of process is becoming as important as the creative itself. Apple, Anthropologie, Prada, Dior, E.l.f. and Loewe have all recently debuted claymation, stop-motion or hand-drawn ads with behind-the-scenes films attached — and posted them on main social feeds, not buried case-study pages.

Greg Lotus, global head of production at VML, remembers a wave of behind-the-scenes demand about a decade ago. Back then it was mostly awards-application fodder. "Nobody really cares about the fact that you had a couple days on a set and shot this toothpaste commercial," he says. The current crop is different: it comes from craft-forward brands with devoted fan bases, and it captures mediums that look good on camera.

'No slop = will shop'

The audience reaction has turned openly grateful. Under Apple's Mac mini video, commenters wrote "Thank you for hiring human animators to make this" and "In a world full of ai commercials, thank you for this apple." Prada's behind-the-scenes video for "Drawing Prada" — featuring former Disney animator John Pomeroy working frame by frame — has 2.8 million views and more than 2,300 comments, many thanking the brand for skipping AI. Under E.l.f.'s spot, which features Alan Cumming narrating over three stop-motion characters, one follower wrote: "No slop = will shop!"

E.l.f. CMO Oshiya Savur said in an email that the brand used no generative AI or CGI: "We're human first, human last at E.l.f. AI can be a useful tool, but the ideas and the taste come from people."

The gratitude has a sharp edge, though. Dior's 7-minute animated holiday film, directed by French animator Sylvain Chomet, came with its own behind-the-scenes video in which Chomet says, "Technically, we work just as they did in the 1940s." Viewers still spotted warped lettering, a lazy eye and a misplaced finger bone, and accused the ad of using AI. The creators denied it, saying an "automated interpolation" system generated in-between frames. LVMH's press department did not respond to a request for comment. Thousands of commenters have turned on the brand anyway, demanding it hire real artists.

"People don't like to be fooled," Lotus says.

How long does the craft wave last?

Notably, none of this proves AI-free ads sell more product — the evidence here is engagement and comment sentiment, not sales. Greenberg thinks the format is peaking: "There's always an extreme to every extreme, and there's been an extreme increase in AI and in questioning what is real and what's not real." That, he argues, drives the opposite extreme — handmade work — which he expects to even out.

MAL's Saulo Rocha predicts audiences will grow more critical as behind-the-scenes content multiplies. "Some brands will tap into it, but for the wrong reasons. That's going to be evident, because now we'll feel smart enough to tell the difference," he says.

Meanwhile, Apple's 2025 puppet-based holiday film "A Critter Carol," directed by MAL's Greg Greenberg, became the brand's most-viewed holiday film ever at 141 million social views — a signal that paying for visible human labor still buys reach that AI-generated assets currently can't.

Source: fastcompany.com

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.

More from Grace Kim →

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »