Creator Economy

A True-Crime Creator Made $154,000 in One Month From Old YouTube Videos

Some creators are turning YouTube back catalogs into sizable paychecks
Some creators are turning YouTube back catalogs into sizable paychecksTemperateSage / pixabay

One true-crime creator earned $154,000 in September from Spotify, Tubi and Facebook — 1.8 times their YouTube Partner Program payout, per Motion Society.

By Sophie Lindqvist

3 min read

At a glance

  • One anonymous true-crime creator earned $154,000 in September across Spotify, Tubi and Facebook — 1.8x their YouTube Partner Program revenue that month.
  • Motion Society distributes over 30,000 videos a month from 650+ creators across 20+ platforms.
  • Motion Society has syndicated creator content since 2022.
  • Tubi licenses creator content, including from Joey Graceffa and Kinigra Deon, via revenue-share deals.

One true-crime creator earned $154,000 in September across Spotify, Tubi and Facebook — 1.8 times what their channel made that same month from the YouTube Partner Program. The figure comes from Chanel Simmons, managing director of the digital media partner Motion Society, who declined to share the exact YouTube payout. The creator requested anonymity.

The numbers signal a shift in how creators monetize. Instead of chasing new audiences, they are squeezing fresh revenue from catalogs they already own. Motion Society has syndicated creator content since 2022, but interest is now at a record. The company works with over 650 creators and IP owners, distributing more than 30,000 videos a month across 20-plus digital platforms and connected-TV services.

What changed in creator strategy?

For Jonathan Chanti, CEO and co-founder of Reign Maker Group, the math points one direction. "The focus is shifting from audience growth to maximizing the value of the content creators already own," he said. "Creators have spent the last decade learning how to produce content at scale. The next challenge is learning how to distribute and monetize it at scale. Syndication is the natural evolution."

Keith Bendes, chief strategy officer at Linqia, frames syndication as a rebuilt version of an old model. "Syndication is kind of like the new MCN, but rebuilt around distribution instead of YouTube ad sales," he said. "The big bonus is that the destinations now pay. So the real value from the syndicators is operational."

Other players include Jellysmack, which has worked with MrBeast and Brad Mondo, and Mirage Digital, which helps creators turn catalogs into episodic content. Agencies and managers can also handle syndication directly, according to Lauren Lyster, vp and head of social media at Go Fish Digital.

Why do platforms want old videos?

Free streaming services need constant programming, and creator libraries arrive with fans attached. Kudzi Chikumbu, vp of creator partnerships at Tubi, said the platform seeks creators with "a compelling, distinctive voice" that aligns with its fandoms in horror, YA and reality. Tubi licenses content from creators including Joey Graceffa, who makes cinematic murder mystery episodes, and Kinigra Deon, who produces scripted drama and comedy. Deals take the form of revenue share.

"Free streaming TV services are especially well positioned," Lyster said, naming Roku, Samsung TV Plus and Pluto TV as other carriers of digital-first content. She called Spotify an "interesting fit" for podcast-style video and Facebook a better home for long-form.

What does the syndication pipeline look like?

Motion Society's process is hands-on, per Simmons and the company's account of its workflow:

  • Curating and sequencing catalog videos into cohesive seasons
  • Re-editing content to TV standards: cutting sponsor reads, social calls to action, watermarks and burned-in captions
  • Removing anything that fails TV brand-safety guidelines
  • Designing original key art per show and season in platform-specific formats
  • A/B testing strategies across platforms

The company takes a revenue share but declined to disclose the split.

What happens to brand deals?

Syndication at scale raises contractual questions. "Who owns the extra reach?" Bendes asked. "If brands are sponsoring the creator's content and it gets syndicated, does that sponsorship carry? Usage rights, exclusivity windows and brand-safety clauses will need to catch up." He expects pricing to move toward TV-style negotiation, with a premium for multi-surface reach and brand pushback demanding proof the reach is real.

Lyster sees a possible future where creators use syndicators the way musicians use distributors to reach every streaming service. Chanti flags the risk: "The biggest risks are creators sacrificing control over their IP, audience relationships or future monetization opportunities for relatively modest short-term gains. Ownership, transparency and favorable licensing terms are critical." As free streaming platforms keep hunting for programming, expect more catalog deals — and harder negotiations over who owns the reach they create.

Source: Digiday

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Correspondent covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.

More from Sophie Lindqvist →

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »