Paid Social

ChatGPT Ads Hit $1B Run Rate — But Return $0.52 Per Dollar vs Google's $3.40

ChatGPT Ads Vs. Google Search Ads: What Early Data Shows
ChatGPT Ads Vs. Google Search Ads: What Early Data ShowsAI-generated

ChatGPT Ads passed a $1B annualized run rate, but early data shows $0.52 revenue per ad dollar vs $3.40 for Google Search — and even that figure rests on borrowed click prices.

By Grace Kim

4 min read

At a glance

  • OpenAI reported a $1 billion annualized ads run rate by Aug. 31, with 100,000+ advertisers since the February launch
  • A working paper found ChatGPT ad sessions generated $0.89 revenue vs $2.45 for paid search in U.S. traffic
  • The widely cited $0.52-per-dollar figure mixes measured revenue with click prices from one ChatGPT account and 16 search accounts
  • Alphabet's Q3 Search & other revenue was $63.35 billion, up 12%
  • New bid options Target CPA and Target CPC launched Nov. 9; Max Bid and Max CPC retire Jan. 1, 2027

By Grace Kim

OpenAI's ads product passed a $1 billion annualized run rate by Aug. 31, with more than 100,000 advertisers running campaigns since the February launch. Yet the most-cited performance figure — $0.52 back per ad dollar versus $3.40 for Google Search — wasn't fully measured. It stitched together one metric from an academic working paper with click prices from a single ChatGPT account and 16 paid search accounts.

That distinction matters if someone proposes shifting your search budget. Here's what the evidence actually says.

What does the data show per visit?

A working paper by researchers Kaiser and Schulze, covered Nov. 2, pooled transaction data from 102 websites across 60 weeks through Aug. 22. In U.S. traffic, paid search generated $2.45 in revenue per session versus $0.89 for ChatGPT ad sessions. Transactions per session came to 1.17% against 0.37%.

The authors' model controlled for website, device and week. Out of 87 advertisers running on both channels, 84 earned less revenue per session from ChatGPT ads. The authors call the work "descriptive rather than causal" — they make no claim that switching matched budgets would help or hurt any specific advertiser.

The Frankfurt School press release turned those figures into value for money: $0.89 ÷ $1.72 per click for ChatGPT, and $2.45 ÷ $0.72 for search. But the $0.52 and $3.40 numbers appear nowhere in the paper's body, and the release doesn't explain the math. The search price is a median from 16 mostly U.S. accounts, not matched to each site's revenue. The ChatGPT price comes from agency Opascope's June report — one account, roughly $60,000 over 15 days, on campaigns scaled after they showed promise, with a 1.49x ROAS.

The paper also carries disclosures: data came from Grips Intelligence, where Kaiser works as a scientific advisor and holds salary plus virtual shares. The authors say Grips played no role in the research.

What did OpenAI say?

An OpenAI spokesperson responded by email, saying the study "captures an earlier period of ChatGPT Ads' development and extrapolates platform performance from a small sample." The company pointed to newer products, including Target CPA and Target CPC. Notably, OpenAI's FAQ says it provides no performance benchmarks, and none of its four help pages I reviewed disclosed click prices across advertisers.

Has money actually moved from Google?

No public figure shows that. Alphabet reported $63.35 billion in Q3 Search & other revenue, up 12%. Chief Business Officer Philipp Schindler cited "the lower monetization we were seeing in AI Mode" as one growth factor, without a figure or baseline. A Bank of America survey of 117 advertisers, reported Oct. 14, named Google Search the most-mentioned potential source of future ChatGPT spend — but it asked about plans, not dollars moved. Google can keep growing while some advertisers test elsewhere.

What do agency case studies show?

The post-click picture is thin:

  • StubGroup (B2B compliance client, 30 days): ChatGPT CPC $0.76 vs Google's $10.46; cost per lead $92.21 vs $157.57; conversion rates 0.8% vs 6.64%. Google leads still convert to customers at a higher rate — though the client's long sales cycle leaves the final answer open.
  • Workshop Digital (self-funded, $2,319 in clicks): ChatGPT CPC $3.14 vs Google's $6.76; CTR 1.1% vs 5.2%; zero qualified leads from ChatGPT, two from Google. The agency called it "not a direct comparison" and didn't disclose Google spend or dates.
  • Brafton (June 17–Aug. 28): $1,524.11 spent, 263 clicks, one form submission. Director of paid media Zach Shah said ChatGPT ads are "priced like search, but seem to behave like paid social."
  • Jotform (OpenAI case study, July internal data): cost per signup roughly 30% less than paid search — with no costs or attribution details provided. Sign-ups aren't sales.

What should practitioners do?

Start with actual spend and attributed revenue on both channels for the same period, using the same attribution settings. Ads Manager counts clicks and may include view-through conversions on 7-, 14- or 30-day windows; analytics counts sessions. Only by assuming clicks equal sessions does that $0.52 figure even compute.

Also report session counts beside revenue — just 18 of 102 sites recorded ChatGPT transactions, and a single zero means different things at 30 visits versus 3,000.

The comparison is about to get harder, not easier. Target CPA and Target CPC went live Nov. 9, legacy API bid fields become average-cost targets from Nov. 18, and Max Bid and Max CPC retire Jan. 1, 2027 — none of which existed during the paper's data window. Documenting objective, bid strategy and attribution window for every Q4 result is what will make next year's numbers comparable at all.

Source: searchenginejournal.com

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.

More from Grace Kim →

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »