Half of U.S. Adults Bought Creator-Recommended Holiday Gifts, Syracuse Survey Finds

Fifty percent of U.S. adults bought creator-recommended holiday gifts in 2025; 85% of them plan to repeat it, and 77% save creator gift ideas, per Syracuse's new survey of 988 adults.
By Marcus Bennett
3 min readAt a glance
- 50% of U.S. adults bought a creator-recommended gift during the September–December 2025 holiday season; 85% of them are likely to repeat it this year.
- Survey of 988 U.S. adults conducted November 7–8, 2026 via Prolific for Syracuse's Center for the Creator Economy Flash Report.
- Instagram (60%), YouTube (59%), and TikTok (53%) lead platforms where shoppers save creator gift ideas.
- 70% of respondents call creator deal promotions 'mostly just advertising,' yet 53% say creators help find deals worth it.
- Creators trail brands narrowly on trust, 53% vs 55%, while AI sits at 47% and celebrities at 25%.
Half of U.S. adults bought at least one holiday gift on a creator's recommendation between September and December 2025, and 85% of those buyers say they're likely to do it again this season. That's the headline finding of Syracuse University's Center for the Creator Economy, published in its second Flash Report dated November 2026.
The survey polled 988 U.S. adults on November 7 and 8 via Prolific, with a sample nationally representative by gender, age, ethnicity, and political affiliation. Respondents ranged from 18 to 84 years old, averaging 45.5. Across all respondents, 61% said they're somewhat or very likely to buy a creator-recommended gift this season. Among those who didn't buy on a creator's recommendation last year, or weren't sure, that figure drops to 22%.
Where does creator influence actually convert?
Creator recommendations peaked on the season's biggest traffic days. Thirty-seven percent of all respondents bought on a creator's recommendation on Black Friday, 26% did so on Cyber Monday, and 33% picked up a creator-recommended item as a last-minute gift.
Saving behavior runs even wider than buying. Seventy-seven percent of U.S. adults save gift ideas from creators, and most do it with other people in mind: 65% save creator posts as gift ideas for others, including 47% who save for both themselves and others. Another 10.6% save only to buy for themselves later; 22.6% don't save creator gift ideas at all. Women and adults aged 18 to 44 were the most likely savers.
Which platforms hold the wish lists?
Among the 765 respondents who save gift ideas, Instagram leads at 60%, followed by YouTube at 59% and TikTok at 53%. Facebook sits at 43.5% and Pinterest at 20.3%. The ranking shifts when shoppers pass ideas along: among the 529 respondents who shared or planned to share saved products as a wish list, Instagram ranks first at 59%, TikTok second at 54%, and YouTube third at 48%.
Do shoppers trust creators or see ads?
Both, apparently. Seventy percent of respondents agree that creators' Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal promotions are "mostly just advertising," with 35% agreeing strongly. Yet 53% agree creators help them find deals that are "actually worth it."
Shoppers also rate their own ad-detection skills. Fifty-six percent are "very" or "extremely" confident they can spot a paid promotion, and 59% say the same about commission links. Confidence falls to 45% when a creator promotes a product received free from a brand.
On trust, friends and family remain untouchable at 75% trusting them "very much" or "completely," with customer reviews at 48%. On a broader moderate-or-higher trust measure, creators hit 53% — just behind brands at 55%, ahead of AI at 47% and celebrities at 25%. Twenty-four percent don't trust AI at all for gift ideas; 39% say the same of celebrities.
Creators also kill purchases. Sixteen percent of respondents, or 158 people, said a creator talked them out of a gift last season. Of that group, 38% were steered to a better-quality alternative, 25% to a cheaper one, and 23% were talked out entirely. Smaller shares cited sustainability (8.2%), crafting the gift instead (3.8%), or experiences over gifts (1.9%).
Which categories move the most?
Beauty and personal care leads creator-influenced gifting at 68%, followed by clothing, shoes, and accessories at 66%, electronics at 64%, and home and kitchen at 61%. Toys and games hit 56%; food and drink and books each reached 52%; health and wellness came in at 46%. Experiences (40%), gift cards (38%), and travel (35%) ranked lowest. Gender was the survey's most consistent divide, with women ahead on saving, buying, and planning creator-recommended gifts.
The Center for the Creator Economy, launched in 2025 as a joint initiative of Syracuse's Newhouse and Whitman schools, publishes these Flash Reports monthly — so practitioners can expect a fresh read on seasonal creator commerce behavior in December.
Source: netinfluencer.com
Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering money, funding and market shifts around Social platform news and policy at Reach Brief.
Related articles
20 Creator Economy Events Span Nine Cities From November 17 to December 10
Creator Content Is Driving Retail Sales — and Brands Have the Numbers
Creator Economy Hits $217B in 2026, But the Top 10% Take 60%
30 Creator Economy Execs Name the Industry's Biggest Unsolved Problem
Nearly Half of Brands Report 3x Return on Creator Marketing